Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

Can the Bible be reliable? Options
PaulSwany
Posted: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 2:46:41 PM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration , Member

Joined: 4/9/2008
Posts: 108
Points: 163
Location: Bartlett
This is a response to a post in another thread:

ProBro_Mofo wrote:
Hello Paul,
I dont want to offend for no good reason. I was raised as a christian but none of it ever "rang true" for me. I will not drone on and on except to answer your questions about him fulfilling prophecies and rising from the dead.

1. The prophecies are made up stories and their is no evidance or proof of any kind supporting that he in fact did perform miracles. Remember that most of this was written hundreds of years after his death... No one who wrote the new testiment was alive during his life time.

2. Rose from the dead :) Thats a cute story too...

If you really believed in Jesus and what he stands for you would be jewish not christian. Jesus didnt say "Yo dude, lets start a whole new religion that is somewhat anti-semetic"... He was a jew and thought he was the messiah from the jewish bible about the jewish messaiah there to save the jews.... Where does christianity or the catholic church come into play? Oh yes... When needing to legitimize a new religion in 5xx A.D. task one= make sure to have plenty of stories deify the guy who the religion is based on.

I believe that belief in God is a good thing, but when I start hearing people say they know what God says, wants, or thinks, 99.9% of the time it has to do with control, power and money and little to do with God. No one knows what God wants thinks or cares about and that is the only real truth out there... The rest is a bunch of stories to make you buy pepsi instead of coke.... I wont say anything elese about it!

Paul, the planes are awesome! I love my Mojo 60 and can honesly say its my favorite of all the 10 planes I own and fly!


Prophecies are not made up stories. They are descriptions of events that took place hundreds of years before the actual event took place. Take the crucifixion. That form of torture wasn't even invented at the time it was prophesied by Isaiah. Non-Christian Jewish historians have written about the events of the bible thus verifying them. 500 people witnessed Jesus in the flesh after He was crucified. Many of these 500 people were put to death because they would not deny Christ’s resurrection. I know some people that would die for a close relative... But I don't know anyone that would die for a lie. All 12 of the disciples where martyred for their belief.

There is nothing anti-semantic about Christianity. Christianity has its roots in Jewish heritage.

What is it about submitting to a power greater than yourself is a problem for you? Your denial of God's existence sounds more like a "I want to do it my way" sort of thing. I'm guessing the only thing that didn't "ring true" was the idea that we are all sinners and need a savior. Most folks that I've talked to about this don't want to deal with the reality that there is a God that has a plan and wants everyone to accept it. For some folks, its easier to define reality by their own parameters so they can be subjective about things.

Putting the cynicism aside and forgetting about what some folks have done in Christ’s name, Why is it about Christ that offends you?
papa T
Posted: Thursday, June 26, 2008 8:32:29 PM
Rank: Member
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/10/2008
Posts: 19
Points: 69
Location: nwo bro
I'd like to say a few things for truth and clarity.
One is not all twelve deciples were martyred, one lived and spread the word and lived, albeit a rough life, even being once shipwrecked, he died naturally.

Saying man wrote the Bible is like saying a court stenographer wrote the transcript. The stenographer is more in the role of copyist than author, as in taking dictation, and the work is verified. If they get it incorrect they dont have a job. Along this line of thought then concider the authors of the Bible more like penmen. The new testament was written contemporaneously. Matter of fact there is evidence of it being written and finished by 70AD. Everyone whom wrote the New Testament was alive during Jesus' lifetime.
One of the biggest problems lies in the word, and practice of, religion. Jesus did not start, have, carry on in, or otherwise be a part of religion.
He was and is Truth incarnate. The best way to understand that is to not believe me or anyone else. You have to search the scriptures for yourself. There are many secular evidences and proofs too mind you. Tacitus and Herodotus have written records that mention the things of the days of Christ. The scroll of Cyrus is irrefutable proof of prophetic writings. 700 years separate the recording from the entry of Cyrus into Jerusalem. Besides Herodotus is concidered the father of historical recording by historians both Christian and secular.

And you can know the will of the Father, not to get someones money or tell you what soda to buy, but by submission to Him and His Word, He will make it known to you. It is about a relationship with Him. Why else would he have sent his Son except his love for us?
ProBro_Mofo
Posted: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 2:28:32 PM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/5/2008
Posts: 7
Points: -173
Location: Montreal
Nothing about Jesus offends me. I honeslty think his story and legacy it quite amazing.

The chritian sales pitch is quite something. "Join us or YOU WILL burn in hell". I mean WOW... who can resist? :) That is one reason why chritianity is viral, and "anti-other religions" by its very nature. What about budism, islaam, etc? I guess they are completely wrong, and its followers going to hell, right? Isint that what a "good" chritian thinks? Please understand that I am not saying Jesus...I am saying chritians... Jesus had nothing to do with chritianity, he was a practicing Jew.

Please be honest... TODAY> if Jesus was in your home town, making his claims... would you believe him, or think "how sad, this delusional megalomanic is in serious need of some mental help assistance"... Dont even bother answering because I already know what the answer is (even if you will not admit it).

Remember that about 1 in 4 people on average have mental health issues... In jesus's day, there was no treatment, yet it was just as common as today if not more so.

I dont have a problem with Jesus's messages of hope and love. I have a major major problem with people who claim to know what God wants. They either are mental, or have another modivation. More than likley it is financial in the moderm age.

Any prophecies or stories that make you believe in the impossible are simply made up or re-written you convince you a story is fact. Unfortunatley its as simple as that my friends.

Look Im not here to rain on your parade. My message is a simple one.... Do not follow false profits.

papa T, I cannot think of any bigger waste of time in life than studing the historical BS which supports the idea that Jesus was a God... Its nonsence and rediculous. I certainly will not study chritican scriptures and history because its boring BS, guy...

I guess afer all your studying you know what God wants and thinks and plans for us, right? Hey maybe your a god too? Please get on your soap box and tell us ignorant peasants what GOD wants. Can anyone say crazy shyte?

What does god look like? A burning bush? An old man with a long white beard? A white man of course!









Join the dark side, we have cookies!
Jesus Freak
Posted: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 8:39:42 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/20/2008
Posts: 2
Points: 6
Location: Gods Country, Tn
God loves you and he wants you to come out of the darkness and into the light. We love you no matter what you say.

Remember, if we are wrong we have had fun fellowshipping with the Brethren, but if you are wrong you will burn in the lake of fire for eternity.

Love ya, mean it!

ProBro_Mofo
Posted: Thursday, August 21, 2008 9:36:40 AM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/5/2008
Posts: 7
Points: -173
Location: Montreal
Jesus Freak wrote:

Remember, if we are wrong we have had fun fellowshipping with the Brethren, but if you are wrong you will burn in the lake of fire for eternity.


Ohh Jesus Freak.... you are too funny!!! Pray
-I guess I beter turn my brain off and hedge my bets so I dont burn in hell, regardless of what I know in my heart of hearts. I believe that this is the core of what 95% of jesus followers think. They dont want to apply the same realisic and pragmatic thinking they apply to every other area of life when it comes to their religion because they know it will make them doubt and not believe, and that could result in some roasting.... non-sence my friend... crazy ass tribal, ancient thinking.

I have always thought that if people would examine the FACTS of the "real life of Jesus" and not the catholic churches "stories", they would see that Jesus was just a man and the myths preached at church have to do with the catholic church Inc. The most successful corperation in history. Selling eternal life and a place right beside god in heaven forever! People do not want to feel insignificant and small... Its much better for the ego to think "I'll live forever with God in the puffy cloud heaven". But all the other animals on the planet will take dirt naps and return to the cosmos.

-Do you think Jesus knew that in the future the sun in our solar system would engulf and encompass the earth as it expands and grows? The earth will be comsumed by our sun and will no longer exist. This is pretty much a certainty, it will happen.... How to that fit into your beliefs?

The bible says all kinds of non-sence that can easily be explained by the fact that it was written in a far less enlightened time, and people simply did not know that one day carbon dating would devulge the age of things on the planet. So they made up stuff like " Man exised on day one of the earths exsitance, and the earth is 13000 years old. What about the fact that the earth is 6 billion years old? What about evolution? What about all the other planets? Did Adam and Eve live there too? Come on guys... lets get real here...

The truth is, you do not want to believe that your life will end and there will be nothing else... You will return to the earth which created you, and thats it... Accept it and get away from your cult... Dont be a puppet to people selling you dreams for cold hard cash... Thats is exaclty what you are doing.






Join the dark side, we have cookies!
Jesus Freak
Posted: Thursday, August 21, 2008 4:42:32 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 8/20/2008
Posts: 2
Points: 6
Location: Gods Country, Tn
Read 1st Corinthians 1:18













I don't like my cookies burnt.
PaulSwany
Posted: Thursday, August 21, 2008 11:24:51 PM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration , Member

Joined: 4/9/2008
Posts: 108
Points: 163
Location: Bartlett
ProBro_Mofo wrote:

I have always thought that if people would examine the FACTS of the "real life of Jesus" and not the catholic churches "stories", they would see that Jesus was just a man and the myths preached at church have to do with the catholic church Inc. The most successful corperation in history. Selling eternal life and a place right beside god in heaven forever! People do not want to feel insignificant and small... Its much better for the ego to think "I'll live forever with God in the puffy cloud heaven". But all the other animals on the planet will take dirt naps and return to the cosmos.


I agree, you really should examine the facts. There are more than the claims of Christs supporters to prove His existance. Take the Jewish Historian Josephus. He wrote about the life and times of Jesus from a Jewish perspective. How about the crucifixion? That was a documented method of execution the Romans used and carried out on Jesus. What about the 500 witnesses that went to their graves claiming they saw Jesus raised from the dead...

Check out your History before you go off writing your own comfortable reality blaming the existence of Christ on the "feel good" people. It's easy to paint what ever face makes it easy for you to continue to deny a power greater than your self on Jesus.

If you're really interested in knowing the truth, I have a book I'd like to send you called the case for Christ. It was written my a journalist that set out to systematically disprove the claims of Christ.
PaulSwany
Posted: Thursday, August 21, 2008 11:26:33 PM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration , Member

Joined: 4/9/2008
Posts: 108
Points: 163
Location: Bartlett
Jesus Freak wrote:
Read 1st Corinthians 1:18


18For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God. 19For it is written:
"I will destroy the wisdom of the wise;
the intelligence of the intelligent I will frustrate."

ProBro_Mofo
Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 9:35:21 AM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/5/2008
Posts: 7
Points: -173
Location: Montreal
Wow, you people are simply not capable of listening or hearing any other opinions, or respecting others beliefs. The answer to anything but complete conformity is "You will burn in hell"... My answer to you is, AWESOME!!!!!!! I cant wait! I'll see you there!

I thought the probros was about free-wheeling good times, partying and hucking.. What does a cult religion and the condisending self rightcious preaching of its endoctrinated puppets have to do with it? Its sad and retarded...

I recommend you keep your religious beliefs in the closet where they belong, becuase your BS is offensive to anyone who doesnt believe what you do.

I dont want to hear what you have to say about your christian beliefs just like I cannot watch a 2 hour program trying to convince me that UFO's and ghosts exist. I wish you people had the capacity to see the truth and how its not a bad thing, its enlightning and liberating to know the truth and not have to have faith in the UFO's and ghosts.

Have chritian leaders and preachers been good examples of a moral and rightcious life, or time and time again do we not see that they are corrupt and greedy and liars. I dont believe in any of it, but I would never cheat you or steal from you because I have morals and know right from wrong... I dont need jebus for that... Think about it..

If you are going to respond with "go read a bible passage, or your going to burn in hell (like the witches used to burn for real because of the other mid-evil thinkers judgements), or the words of joe-blow profit guy" I say, dont bother... I am talking about facts and reality... you go on talking about your profits and stories... I will file them in my mind right next to the ufo sitings and ghost stories nonsence I hear as well.


Join the dark side, we have cookies!
PaulSwany
Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 10:44:46 AM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration , Member

Joined: 4/9/2008
Posts: 108
Points: 163
Location: Bartlett
First off, this is NOT the ProBro Site and we are not about "free-wheeling good times, partying and hucking..." I enjoy flying model airplanes and having a good time, but debauchery is no longer something I wish to be a part of.

This particular forum is devoted to bible study. This is not a religious cult and no one here is trying to be self righteous or condescending.... You are free to hold what ever beliefs you find suitable. You are free to debate your beliefs if you wish as I always encourage a good debate... You are NOT free to bash others for what they believe.

My best advice to you is to visit websites that espouse your particular believes. As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.
ProBro_Mofo
Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 7:39:05 PM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 6/5/2008
Posts: 7
Points: -173
Location: Montreal
Paul, that was very well stated and I have to respect the statement and agree. I have been bashing your beliefs and its not right. Please accept my sincere apology, and thank you of not censoring me.

Good Posting

I do not really have anything new to contribute on the topic matter itself and I guess we will have to agree to disagree about Jesus and knowing the will of God. As they say don’t argue religion and politics, but I like a spirited debate. Also, please accept my denigrations for what they really are; ignorant representations meant express and illustrate my true feelings on the subject matter; stated in a blunt rude mannor.

ahhh debating the mysteries of the universe! what fun.
d'oh!

Join the dark side, we have cookies!
Devin82m
Posted: Thursday, September 25, 2008 12:21:45 PM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/25/2008
Posts: 3
Points: 9
Location: Millington, TN
I found this discussion interesting. One point made by ProBro was the Catholic Church... As for "Church" history the Catholic Church hasn't helped real followers of Christ just like the evil "televangelists" mislead ignorant and desperate people. I hate hearing my personal, growing, powerful, and loving relationship with Christ being put in the same category with the Catholic Church, which the media does a lot. The Catholic Church and the televangelists don't follow ALL of God’s word. It is as simple as that. Now saying that, God says we are all sinners in His eyes (Romans 3:9-18) and in that way we can compare our selves with the Catholic Church and the televangelists. The Catholic Church was not and still is not following God’s word. They have hatefully persecuted, tortured, murdered, kept people ignorant, distorted truth, worship idols (Mary and the “Saints”), and a myriad of other things in the name of the God of the Bible.
But to me they are no different than the Muslims that claim they follow the Karan and Ala but don’t fight Jihad like the Karan says they should. They are supposed to subdue and force Islam on the non believers as a duty. There are Muslims that claim they are “peaceful” and don’t act like the “extremists” but there is nothing extreme about the terrorist, they are just following what the Karan says in it’s entirety. I have read some of the Karan, trust me it is very demanding and cold. But we Christians claim to follow all of God’s word and we fail just like the above examples. God wants us to be set apart from the world (Morals and denying the flesh) and to express love; we fail at that on a regular basis. Trust me I have been in churches that have so called pastors that have affairs and embesseled money. But I didn’t attribute those examples to a failure on God’s part or a weakness of the word of God. Or did I just give up on God and what he said, I recognized that those people were not being obedient to God just like I fail Him on a regular basis. Of course those pastors shouldn’t be in the ministry any more though because they ARE held to a higher standard. By the way that includes the pastors and priests who have abused children as well (just coving all skeptical bases). But God has given us a way out of condemnation through the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross and his resurrection. We shouldn’t use His sacrifice as a ticket to sin, but we can’t be perfect either.
All this is to say there is so much depth and love to Jesus and what He came to tell us, but more than just a message from a good man. It is a word from THE WORD. Not only can we believe in Christ’s resurrection but also the accuracy of His word. Not only based on Paul’s examples but also on history, archeology, and other personal accounts. I mean even when Mary came back from the tomb to say that Christ’s body was gone, is a good example. In the Jewish culture at the time a woman’s testimony was worth nothing in court, so why would anyone say a woman discovered and announced this information if the followers faked the resurrection after Christ’s death. Another example, archeologists have found the remains of Egyptian chariots and armor in the “Red Sea” (parting of the Red Sea) Even all the hundreds of little prophecies that pertain to the Messiah became true. Like Paul said that the Messiah would be hung on a tree. Archeologists found the remains of Jericho and they say the walls look like they fell. You could say well there just happen to be an earthquake or some natural disaster that corresponds to all these supposed miracles. But the timing based on the goals and actions of the people of the time seem to me to be more than a coincidence with there being so many incidents in the Bible. Even now days there is story after story of people being healed from cancer and other disease after people pray for and with them. Yes a mental change can help but completely remove cancer that’s way different. Doctors have said they couldn’t explain the recoveries. I mean being hopeful hasn’t helped non believers overcome cancer COMPLETELY. What has basic hope done for anyone? So you accomplish some earthly goals, but it doesn’t last. Hope with an eternal perspective on the other hand is powerful.
I have typed so much I want to stop now (everyone cheers). If someone is a true tree seeker and a true debater than they will explore all sides of the Christian argument, including apologetics and historical facts. If I were a skeptic I would want to make SURE what Christians claim is untrue, because your eternal destination may depends on it. What do fleshly thing like sex, power, greed, and knowledge offer you if you die? Also no one is condemning you (if they are it isn’t Biblical) and no one is attacking you, remember we are all sinners in God’s eyes. Also remember the Bible is the most accurate and best selling book in the world, even more accurate than Homer’s Odyssey for centuries now. Don’t take the best selling part wrong. I have been a true seeker for many years even after I came into a personal relationship with Christ. A debate is always good, God says in His word “Come sit and reason with me” he invites you to question Him and His claims. But you can’t do that if you believe you know EVERYTHING about the Christian God and immediately dismiss Him. There are Christians out there that will willingly discuss the claims and statements of Christ. Now granted some people just don’t know God’s word well enough (I include my self in that) and can’t offer much more than love and encouragement, which is very important as well for a hurting person. But there is more than enough out there for people who have questions and disputes. The key to all this is openness and honesty, not insults and shutting down of the discussion. Well that was my 5 million cents; you can take it or leave it!

God bless and I hope God reveals him self to those who ask Him to but don’t yet believe,

-Devin St. Clair (For not being Catholic funny name huh?!) Rock On
Devin82m
Posted: Thursday, September 25, 2008 1:05:37 PM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/25/2008
Posts: 3
Points: 9
Location: Millington, TN
Oh by the way... Astronomers have found every galaxy in the universe has a super giant black hole at the center of it... If you look at these galaxies with black holes in the center it sure does resemble a cell or atom. Also carbon dating has been disproven many times by non biased studies many times to be inaccurate by billions, millions, hundreds of thousands, and tens of thousands of years. World renowned labs have tested some of the same objects and come up with VERY different results. Like one fossil being dated at 1 million years old to 600 million... Yet they still use it to force the assumption that evolution is true. The Smithsonian has a huge record of cover ups and mistakes just look them up, including by the way the creation of supposed link fossils. Normal scientists (non Christians even) have found dating by the rate argon molecules escape from rocks and crystals much more accurate. It's like the global warming debate, it isn't decided that’s the end of it. There are many gasses that seep through the atmosphere much more slowly than carbon dose. Again all this points back to if you are a true seeker than you will look at all sides of the debate for ignorantly and stubbornly dismissing them. So many evolutionists and college professors say we Christians MAKE people follow our ways and force our self upon others. But I say that happens in our education system, when evolution hasn't been proven and it is still a theory we are not allowed to debate it... When everything is looked at through the eyes of an evolutionist sometimes the facts won't come out, only preconceived ideas that are really stretching. Including the fact man believe we evolved from the backs of crystals (renowned evolutionist claim this). Evolutionists don’t want to come to terms with the fact that they are in a religion. Faith in what is not seen or proven and where they force their belief on others sounds like a religion to me.


Resources:

http://www.icr.org/rate/ Disputes carbon dating in extreme detail (science stuff).

http://www.answersingenesis.org/ Very scientific studies.


God bless,

-Devin St. Clair
PaulSwany
Posted: Friday, September 26, 2008 12:12:52 AM

Rank: Administration
Groups: Administration , Member

Joined: 4/9/2008
Posts: 108
Points: 163
Location: Bartlett
Awesome stuff Devin... Apologetics has always been an interesting topic for me....
Devin82m
Posted: Friday, September 26, 2008 10:28:00 AM

Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/25/2008
Posts: 3
Points: 9
Location: Millington, TN
Same here, but I am learning not to go to far into the academic side these day. I have not learned to love the way God loves and wants me to love. We can out fact and out argue someone to the floor. But what good is it if I don't do it in a loving way and point to God's compassionate love toward us as believers and for those that resist that love? Wow, how much longer will I go before I allow God to work His love in and through me...?

-Devin
John Wells
Posted: Tuesday, November 11, 2008 9:59:19 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 11/11/2008
Posts: 1
Points: 3
Location: K.C.
My first post in here. Hey Devin, have you guys seen the movie called Expelled? Ben Stein researched teachings of evolution and I agree with his views about it. IMO, there is a push to get religion out of schools and society. Check it out, it should be on DVD now. I was one of like 3 or 4 people at the show when I watched it. I guess it wasn't too popular, but it hit the nail right on.

I'm a Christian and grew up with a Catholic Father and Pentecostal Mother.

I enjoy the History Channel and a lot of the stuff they air, but I noticed that they usually try to debunk the bible and Christ on religious issues / topics.


JW
Users browsing this topic
Guest


Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Main Forum RSS : RSS

YAFVision Theme Created by Jaben Cargman (Tiny Gecko)
Powered by Yet Another Forum.net version 1.9.1.7 (NET v2.0) - 11/20/2007
Copyright © 2003-2006 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
This page was generated in 0.457 seconds.